Skip to content
Fakta Perspektiv

Parents Who Record Their Kids Weeping for Engagement Should Reflect at Themselves

A specific song has been residing in my head the past seven days, and no, it isn't from Taylor Swift's recent album. It comes by a much more sophisticated composer: a children's entertainer. The song is called Big Feelings and its lyrics declare: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”

The Growth of Intense Reactions On the Internet

Because of the popularity for conscious parenting, the concept of “big feelings” has become profitable on the web, and mostly I welcome that. Being a parent, strong emotions are challenging to escape: you're experiencing them, the youngster in your house is feeling them and, in one of the largest changes for us as a society, so are numerous other children on your social media feed.

In fact, recordings of babies and children weeping is so widespread on certain platforms that a lot of parents accept it without thought. I avoid TikTok and my Instagram feed is mostly fixated on stew and magic, but when a friend expressed that she considered the practice disturbing, not to mention morally dubious, I watched some of the recordings myself.

What I Saw: Children at Their Most Vulnerable

My findings was video after video of children at their most fragile. Weeping, shouting, shrieking, and sometimes lashing out physically. I have naturally been witness to these moments in my own residence, but observing a different child enduring it feels profoundly disturbing, notably when that child is without reassurance by their own parent. Most unacceptable is a genre of video in which parents subject their children to nasal suction while their little one cries and screams straight at the lens. It must be noted that the majority of the videos are not as extreme, and yet there is still something disturbing about them all.

When Strong Emotions Aren't Traumatic

Naturally, “big feelings” aren't always entirely distressing. When your child is sprawling on the ground distraught at the discovery that cake isn't infinite it can be challenging to keep a straight face. A lot of us have been regaled with stories of notably memorable meltdowns of our own. My own involved yelling “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the lobby of the a modern art venue in downtown. Lightheartedly joking your child about a time they had a outburst, or laughing about it with your significant other once they have gone to bed, is acceptable. Capturing a child in a situation of distress and sharing it to the online world for all to see lacking approval is a different matter entirely.

Disturbing Phenomena and Humiliation

Furthermore you have the practices that are plainly concerning, such as one that involved shocking babies to stop crying by flinging a processed food at their heads, or cracking an egg on them. This content seems aimed at shaming children. In a report for the a major publication, a journalist stated: “The most unsettling part of these videos [is that] the parents are scarcely interacting with their kids. Instead they are relating to a mirror image of their children that they are sharing online. And they are enjoying their authority over that image.”

The Defense of Learning Moments

Some video makers who would abhor this kind of content. They assert that they are capturing their children at their most fragile not to ridicule them, but because they are trying to develop teachable moments – “see how serenely and effectively I was able to resolve this child’s tantrum using these techniques”. Several even attempt to avoid expected criticism. “This video is posted to educate and raise awareness – not for support or views”, one video, shared by an account run by a child doctor, supposedly says. The statement that comes after is one of the most self-praising nonsense I have read on the online. “If you haven't experienced the life, refrain from criticizing the moment.”

A Challenge of Obligation

What if you don’t post the moment? I often wonder. Because I absolutely question these people. My perception, when I view a video of a youngster in distress, whether their parent is demonstrating reassurance or not, is a dereliction of duty – the obligation to be present for your child. And I wonder what message it sends, where when your child starts expressing a “big feeling”, you get your phone out. How does that reflect to your child about their wholly natural emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, apparently.

Thoughts on Modern Upbringing

When my partner and I begin touring schools for our son, it’s hard not to think about how approaches to child development have shifted since we were small. There is an increased understanding of the fact that “big feelings” are normal for youngsters. Nowadays many adults aim to acknowledge those emotions and provide children a safe space in which to express themselves. But regardless of what the gentle parenting influencers claim, I don’t believe you can truly offer a secure environment for your child if you are filming their instances of vulnerability and violating their confidentiality and dignity in the procedure. To be frank, I do not believe these people have much to teach any of us about child-rearing.

A Final Thought

Certain individuals who will consider that harsh, who would object to the fact that in certain respects I’d rather put a piece of cheese on my son's head for a giggle than take advantage of his distress as a learning opportunity for views. But to them I would say this: if “all behavior is expression”, what, specifically, are these adults trying to say?

The writer

Walter Johns

A seasoned journalist and political analyst with over a decade of experience covering Nordic and European affairs, focusing on data-driven storytelling.

Fakta Perspektiv

Type to search articles.